I have to say I was quite surprised when I read this book. At first I had this expectation that the book was going to be about life's greatest lessons from a father to a son through the movies they watched together. In a sense I was right, but at the same time, I couldn't be farther from the truth. The book is more about the inbetween exchanges and experiences away from the Film Club. I have never read anything prior this book of David Gilmour's work. So when I started reading his words, he first struck me as a snob...a movie snob. One of those people that knows it all about movies and could debate you under the table about things most common movie goers would say..,"huh?".Anyway, the story starts out with Gilmour's son Jesse struggling in school and the problem he faced with his son not wanting to be in school. So Gilmour decided that he would make Jesse an offer. An offer that probably none of us has ever gotten from a parent-quit school and watch three movies a week with their parent. Of course there was restrictions to letting his son quit school and start The Film Club. Gilmour allowed his son to live rent free, allows him to sleep in as late as he wants and gives him spending money as long as he didn't catch his son doing drugs and then the deal was off. He even let him go without having a job. To me that has to be the strangest thing of them all. However, Jesse later on in the book has some odd jobs.
Jesse isn't your normal teenage boy either, he knows his wines and is allow to smoke in front of his parents. A side note is that Gilmour moves back in with his ex-wife (the mother of Jesse) at her request and even Gilmours current wife agrees to it. Now his ex-wife doesn't end up living in the house she moves above what Gilmour calls the "candy factory". Since I am not familar with his previous work I didn't get the reference.
There are many ups and downs in the book regarding the circumstances that Jesse finds himself in and yet his father remains there for his son and all the movies they watch over a three year span. Some movies are watched multiple times. However, it is the narrative of the events between the films that Gilmour and Jesse experience that makes the book so readable. Jesse gets involved with several girls and two throughout the book that he has problems getting over which leads him into drinking and doing drugs. Gilmour confronts Jesse the first time drugs are involved and was about the end the agreement he made; however, Jesse admits that his father never caught him doing it. He only knew because Jesse told him.
At the beginning of chapter nine, Gilmour discusses going past Jesse's now vacant room and sensing the loss of his presense. I was very upset at Gilmour for making such a comment in the book about halfway through. I had this impression that Jesse ended up dying and this was a book about him remembering that limited time he had with his son. Thankfully, it was not the case and it was just a father experiencing empty nest pains from a son who only now visits him.
As a movie fan myself, I have to say Gilmour puts me to shame. Not in a bad way, but as he being a certified film critic in Canada he has experienced a lot more film genres from all over and draws upon those films in educating his son. (The back of the book actually lists every single film they watched.) I admit, sadly, that only a few of the movies on their list I actually watched. I don't know if that is a good thing or bad thing, but everyone does have their own particular tastes.
I think that is a big difference that I see with people when it comes to the movies. The general audience are going to go to the "popcorn" movies-an escape for two hours without having to think about their problems or want to think about what they are seeing. It is that escape. There are times, in the book, that Gilmour appears to be just speaking to the reader about why he loves a certain movie then goes back into the narrative of the story of Jesse. I think those were the times, I didn't enjoy the book. It came across, to me anyway, as him being a movie snob. When I catch those movie review shows and they tend to give their opinion about it the movies for the general audience tend to get reviewed poorly and yet are the movies (for the most part) that do big at the box office. Similar to our government officials, movie reviewers, are out of touch with their public. I am a huge "popcorn" movie person and I am not afraid to admit it.
There were a lot of great exchanges between father and son in this book and one of the best quotes came from Gilmour early on regarding seeing a movie for the first time. He stated that a person doesn't see a movie the first time until it is viewed the second time. His reasoning is that when you go back to the movie knowing how it ends you start to look for how the story is woven to get to the ending and it makes you appericate what was put into the film.
I have to say even though I felt that Gilmour at times was tooting his own movie knowledge horn, that "The Film Club" is a great read and I hated when I had to put it down when I couldn't sit for long periods to read the book. Even if you are not a movie buff or someone that has seen a lot of the movies listed (me included), I think this book is a definate recommended book for anyone who remembers sitting at home watching movies as a kid or teenager with their parents. Good memories.
The Lowdown:
Title: The Film Club
Author: David Gilmour
Released: 2008
Price: $21.95 (hardback) I found this at a local used book store for much less.
Publisher: Twelve Books http://www.twelvebooks.com/
Again, if anyone has media related books or anything you want me to review please contact me or comment on the website. Until next time!
